Internal Control · 2024
In this section9 topics
- Internal Control — Board Opinion1 item
- Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System1 item
- Internal Control Deficiencies1 item
- Audit Committee & Auditor Observations2 items
- Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Related Party Transactions1 item
- Counterparties & Transactions3 items
- Policy & Future Trends2 items
Internal Control — Board Opinion
Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control
The Company places great importance on good and effective internal control, which is a mechanism that reflects good corporate governance for the ultimate benefit of shareholders and all stakeholders. The Company has therefore established an internal control policy to serve as the basis for a sound internal control system in accordance with international standards. In addition, the Company has engaged an external internal audit firm (Outsource), S.P. Plus Advisory Co., Ltd., since April 1, 2021 to audit the internal control system, which will report directly to the Audit Committee. As of November 8, 2022, the date of the 2/2022 Audit Committee meeting (PCL), the Company had a total of 3 Audit Committee members to review the adequacy of the Company's internal control system and to ensure that the Company conducts its business in accordance with the principles of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Public Company Act, the Securities and Exchange Act, or other regulations related to the Company and/or the Company's business.
The Company places great importance on good and effective internal control, which is a mechanism that reflects good corporate governance for the ultimate benefit of shareholders and all stakeholders. The Company has therefore established an internal control policy to serve as the basis for a sound internal control system in accordance with international standards. In addition, the Company has engaged an external internal audit firm (Outsource), S.P. Plus Advisory Co., Ltd., since February 1, 2024, to audit the internal control system, which will report directly to the Audit Committee. As of February 20, 2024, the date of the 1/2024 Audit Committee meeting, the Company had a total of 3 Audit Committee members to review the adequacy of the Company's internal control system and to ensure that the Company conducts its business in accordance with the principles of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Public Company Act, the Securities and Exchange Act, or other regulations related to the Company and/or the Company's business.
The company has entered into a sales contract with a business partner. However, due to the inefficiency and lack of rigor in the internal control system for contract management, an operational level employee of the company forged the partner's signature on the contract. After the company became aware of the matter, a meeting of the Board of Directors was held and a fact-finding committee was appointed to investigate the facts of the incident. It was found that the forgery of the signature on the contract with the business partner was an offense committed by the head of the department who was the coordinator for the signing of the amended sales contract. As the coordinator, he had not yet received the signed contract from the partner, which caused him to be concerned that he would not be able to submit the document on time. Coupled with the expectation that the counterparty would sign, he arbitrarily signed it himself, fearing that the absence of the document would cause damage to the company.
The company has entered into a sales contract with a business partner. However, due to the inefficiency and lack of rigor in the internal control system for contract management, an operational level employee of the company forged the partner's signature on the contract. After the company became aware of the matter, a meeting of the Board of Directors was held and a fact-finding committee was appointed to investigate the facts of the incident. It was found that the forgery of the signature on the contract with the business partner was an offense committed by the head of the department who was the coordinator for the signing of the amended sales contract. As the coordinator, he had not yet received the signed contract from the partner, which caused him to be concerned that he would not be able to submit the document on time. Coupled with the expectation that the counterparty would sign, he arbitrarily signed it himself, fearing that the absence of the document would cause damage to the company.
However, the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors assessed the adequacy of the internal control system for contract management and agreed that the company's internal control system for contract management was not sufficiently rigorous. The Audit Committee therefore instructed the internal auditor to conduct three additional specific audits of the internal control system for contract management between July and September 2024. The company and the Audit Committee used the results of the internal audit to improve the internal control system for contract management by establishing policies and procedures for contract management to ensure that the company has properly executed contracts for all of its actual transactions, including the proper and appropriate storage of both soft and hard copies of contracts, with a good control system in place to prevent forgery, misrepresentation, or misuse of contracts in the future. The policies and procedures for contract management are as follows:
• Policy on document signing and use
• Policy on Contract Amendment
• Document Control Procedures
• Contract Classification Policy
The Company has assigned the legal department to be responsible for overseeing all employees to comply with the policies and procedures for contract management and to report any incidents or actions that are not in accordance with the policies and procedures for contract management. The legal department is also required to report a summary of all contracts entered into by the Company with its business partners on a quarterly basis to the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors at their quarterly meetings.
After the improvement of the company's internal control system for contract management, the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors agreed that the internal control system for contract management was sufficiently effective and appropriate to prevent incomplete and inaccurate contracts, forgery of signatures on contracts, or misuse of the company's contracts.
After the improvement of the company's internal control system for contract management, the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors agreed that the internal control system for contract management was sufficiently effective and appropriate to prevent incomplete and inaccurate contracts, forgery of signatures on contracts, or misuse of the company's contracts.
For the internal control audit of the information system, due to the nature of the company's business, it is not a business that requires the use of information systems to calculate financial transactions like banking, securities, or insurance businesses that require the use of information systems to calculate principal, interest, or the amount to be paid in financial transactions. Therefore, the internal auditor considers that the IT General Control audit is sufficient for the IT Control audit. The details of the internal auditor's review of the company's information system control points are as follows:
For the internal control audit of the information system, due to the nature of the company's business, it is not a business that requires the use of information systems to calculate financial transactions like banking, securities, or insurance businesses that require the use of information systems to calculate principal, interest, or the amount to be paid in financial transactions. Therefore, the internal auditor considers that the IT General Control audit is sufficient for the IT Control audit. The details of the internal auditor's review of the company's information system control points are as follows:
Input stage:
The internal auditor verifies the accuracy of documents and data entry, as well as the document verification and approval process.
Processing stage:
The system is an ERP system, which is a standard system. The company has not developed any additional programs. The processing part is considered reliable.
Output stage:
The auditor has reviewed both the documentary and numerical information in the financial statements, which are considered the output of the system. The ERP system produces accurate and reliable output.
Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System
Internal Control Framework Used
| Framework | Detail |
|---|---|
| COSO - Enterprise Risk Management Framework (ERM) | Overview of Internal Control System under the COSO Framework of Miss Grand International Company Limited (Public Company) from the Internal Control Adequacy Assessment Report of Miss Grand International Company Limited (Public Company) for the year 2014, it was found that the Company has implemented internal control in accordance with the COSO (Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission) framework, which consists of 5 main components: 1. Control Environment • The Company places importance on corporate values, ethics, and business conduct. • The Board of Directors and management have established clear governance guidelines and policies. • Roles, responsibilities, and accountability are defined for executives and employees at all levels. • Conflicts of interest are prevented, and strict anti-corruption measures are implemented. Assessment Result: The Company has a corporate culture that promotes ethics and transparency. 2. Risk Assessment • The Company identifies and analyzes potential risks from both internal and external factors. • The Risk Management Committee is responsible for monitoring and assessing the impact of key risks. • Opportunities for fraud are assessed, and measures are in place to prevent damage. • Organizational goals are reviewed and considered to align with operational capabilities. Assessment Result: The Company has a comprehensive and systematic risk management approach. 3. Control Activities • The Company establishes internal control measures such as segregation of duties and authorization limits. • Clear rules and procedures are in place for financial transactions and procurement. • Preventive measures and monitoring of operations are in place to reduce the opportunity for fraud. • Information technology is used for control purposes, such as setting data access permissions. Assessment Result: The Company's internal control measures are rigorous and appropriate. 4. Information & Communication • The Company emphasizes internal communication to ensure that employees are aware of and comply with internal control policies. • Communication channels and reporting mechanisms for fraud are available, such as email, complaint boxes, and online channels. • An information technology system is in place to support data management and internal control. • Key information is systematically reported to the Board of Directors and management. Assessment Result: The Company's internal communication and information management systems are effective. 5. Monitoring Activities • The Company has an internal audit function performed by an independent unit that reports to the Audit Committee. • The internal control system is monitored and evaluated periodically. • Internal control measures are reviewed and updated to align with business changes. Assessment Result: The Company's monitoring and evaluation system ensures the ongoing effectiveness of internal control. From the assessment of the internal control system of Miss Grand International Company Limited (Public Company), it was found that the internal control system is adequate and appropriate in accordance with the principles of COSO and complies with the regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). However, continuous development and improvement should be made to support business growth and changes in the economic and legal environment. Strengths : The internal control system covers all COSO components and has good safeguards. Recommendations : Continuous employee training and further development of the IT security system are recommended. |
| The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) | Executive Summary of the Adequacy and Appropriateness of the Internal Control System from the Internal Control Adequacy Assessment Report of Miss Grand International Public Company Limited for the year 2024, conducted by SP Plus Advisory Company Limited, found that the Company's internal control system is adequate and appropriate for achieving the organization's objectives, including compliance with the criteria of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Key issues are as follows: 1. Compliance with Internal Control Guidelines • The company complies with the COSO framework, which consists of 5 main components: control environment, 1. Risk Assessment 2. Control Activities 3. Information and Communication 4. Follow-up activities 2. Overall Assessment Results • The company's internal control system is rigorous and appropriate for business operations. • There are measures to prevent and detect fraud, including the establishment of clear ethical and code of conduct guidelines. • There is a proper segregation of duties and authorization to reduce operational risks. 3. Risk Management • The company assesses and manages risks at all levels of the organization, covering both internal and external factors. • The company monitors and considers the potential risks of fraud and establishes appropriate preventive measures. 4. Use of Information Technology • The company has information technology control measures in place to enhance data security and accuracy. • Data access rights are defined to prevent unauthorized access risks. 5. Recommendations for Further Development • Although the company's internal control system is adequate and appropriate, the internal control process should be continuously improved and reviewed. • Employees should be trained periodically to understand and comply with internal control standards. |
Internal Control Deficiencies
Number of Deficiencies
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Audit Committee & Auditor Observations
Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's
No
Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control
No
Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Head of Internal Audit
3160
Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
The Company has appointed S.P. Plus Advisory Co., Ltd. as its internal auditor to review and assess the Company's internal control system. The objective is to provide recommendations for improving the work systems of the Company and its subsidiaries to ensure adequate and effective internal control in accordance with the guidelines of The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO), to have good corporate governance, transparency, and auditability, as well as to have appropriate operating systems in various areas. In the past, the internal auditor has continuously submitted internal audit reports and issue follow-up reports of the Company since 2021. The reports can be classified into 2 types as follows:
(1) Internal Control Adequacy Assessment Report (Pre-IA)
This report is to assess the process of preparing the operational manual, regulations, and authorization, and to assess the adequacy of the current internal control system. After the audit, the Company has continuously improved and corrected significant issues and has instructed the internal auditor to plan regular audits until the overall internal audit of the entire Company has been fully addressed. The internal auditor did not find any issues from the audit. Subsequently, the Company has assigned the internal auditor to conduct internal audits on a quarterly basis.
(2) Quarterly Internal Audit and Issue Follow-up Report
Quarterly internal audit and issue follow-up reports of Miss Grand International Co., Ltd. (Public Company), which the Company has audited from the first quarter of 2021 to the fourth quarter of 2022, which is the most recent quarter. A total of 16 reports have been issued (excluding the Pre-IA audit report). Each report is divided into a quarterly audit report and a follow-up report on the correction of issues from the previous audit. After each audit of the Company, if any issues are found, the Company will be followed up on the outstanding issues on a quarterly basis. Since the first quarter of 2021, the Company has been subject to a rotation of audits of all systems. All important systems have been audited on a rotating basis until the fourth quarter of 2022, which found that the Company has completely resolved all outstanding issues. In the fourth quarter of 2022, the internal auditor followed up on 3 outstanding issues identified in the third quarter of 2022 and found that the Company had completely resolved all 3 issues in the fourth quarter of 2022.
Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit
Requires Audit Committee Approval
No
Description
-
Related Party Transactions
Has Related Party Transactions
Yes
Counterparties & Transactions
Monetary Unit
1
Counterparties with Potential Conflicts
| Name | Person / Juristic Person | Type of Business | Nature of Relationship | As of Date (YYYY-MM-DD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nawat Itsaragrisil | Person | Authorized Director, Chief Executive Officer, and Major Shareholder of the Company | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| KMGIGroup | Juristic Person | Wholesale and retail of cosmetics | Joint venture | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Ratchapon Chantaratim | Person | Authorized Director, Deputy Chief Executive Officer, and Major Shareholder of the Company | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Saksit Boonvanich | Person | Authorized Director, Chief Financial Officer, and Shareholder of the Company | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Yupawan Chaiwisut | Person | Executive Director / Chief Operating Officer and Shareholder of the company | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Sopana Virulmas | Person | Executive Director / Chief Commercial Officer and Shareholder of the Company | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
Transactions by Counterparty
| Transactions |
|---|
| 325503.0 · Necessity: The company has leased land and buildings, namely two 3-storey townhomes, to be used as branch offices. · Description: Lease of building to be used as company office · As of yesteryear: 325503.0 · Nature of transaction: Property Rental Listing · Audit committee opinion: The list is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
| 3206111.0 · Necessity: The Company entered into a joint venture with Karmarts Public Company Limited to establish KMGI Co., Ltd. on February 20, 2023. The registered capital was 1 million baht, with a shareholding ratio of 50:50. The purpose of this joint venture is to manufacture and distribute cosmetics and skincare products to expand the customer base. On June 22, 2023, KMGI increased its registered capital to 10 million baht. KMGI has been developing products and started production for sale since the third quarter of 2023. The Company has purchased products from KMGI for resale to customers five times, totaling 1.76 million baht. The purchase price from KMGI is comparable to the market price. These transactions arose from the Company's ordinary course of business, which is trading. · Description: Purchase of goods for resale · As of yesteryear: 1239243.6 · Nature of transaction: Purchase Order and Sales Invoice / Be a Partner · Audit committee opinion: This is an appropriate list. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 1000000.0 · Necessity: Artist endorsement services, with Charlotte Austin as the presenter for KMGI's products, valued at 1.00 million baht. The selling price is comparable to the standard rate. · Description: Selling Presenter · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Purchase Order and Sales Invoice / Be a Partner · Audit committee opinion: It is an appropriate list. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
Policy & Future Trends
Policy, Measures & Approval Process
The Company has established a policy and guidelines for related party transactions, which have been reviewed and approved by the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 3/2022 on May 23, 2022. If the Company needs to engage in related party transactions with persons who may have a conflict of interest or have a stake in the transaction, the Company will have the Audit Committee provide an opinion on the necessity and appropriateness of such transactions. In the event that the Audit Committee does not have expertise in considering potential related party transactions, the Company will have the Company's independent expert provide an opinion on such related party transactions for the Audit Committee and/or the Board of Directors and/or shareholders, as the case may be, to use in making their decision. All related party transactions must be carried out in accordance with the regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission on connected transactions and/or the acquisition or disposal of assets, as well as other relevant laws. In addition, persons who may have a conflict of interest or have a stake in the transaction will not be entitled to vote on the approval of such related party transactions. The Company's policy on related party transactions is classified by type of transaction as follows:
• Ordinary Business Transactions and Transactions Supporting Ordinary Business For example, the purchase and sale of goods and services of the Company. In the case of ordinary business transactions or transactions supporting ordinary business with general commercial terms, which refers to trading terms with fair prices and conditions that do not result in the transfer of benefits, the Company will seek approval from the Board of Directors for the guidelines on related party transactions to be used as a guideline for conducting related party transactions. The authorized persons shall consider and approve the transactions in accordance with the authorization manual. However, the Company will present information and details of ordinary business transactions or transactions supporting ordinary business to the Audit Committee for their consideration, review, and opinion on the rationale and necessity of such transactions on a quarterly basis. The Company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the SEC and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on the disclosure of connected transactions.
• Ordinary Business Transactions and Transactions Supporting Ordinary Business without General Commercial Terms or Other Transactions Apart from the Aforementioned Ordinary Business Transactions and Transactions Supporting Ordinary Business For example, lease agreements, property sale or purchase transactions, or financial assistance. In the event that the Company engages in ordinary business transactions and transactions supporting ordinary business without general commercial terms, or other transactions apart from the aforementioned ordinary business transactions and transactions supporting ordinary business, the Company has a policy that the Audit Committee will consider and provide an opinion on the rationale and necessity of such transactions. And/or in the event that there is no market price that can be used as a reference because the goods or services under the transaction are unique or for any other reason, the Company may have an independent expert consider, review, and provide an opinion on the appropriateness of the price and the reasonableness of the transaction. The Company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the SEC and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on the disclosure of connected transactions and the acquisition or disposal of significant assets of the Company. The Company does not have a policy of lending money to persons who may have a conflict of interest to operate a business or operate on behalf of the Company. This is to ensure that the decision to enter into such transactions does not create a conflict of interest and is in the best interests of all shareholders. The Company will disclose such related party transactions in the Company's Annual Registration Statement (Form 56-1 One Report) and the notes to the financial statements audited by the Company's auditor. In addition, if any transaction is not an ordinary course of business for both parties, it must be submitted to the Audit Committee for consideration and approval by the Board of Directors before proceeding with the transaction. As the Company may have related party transactions with directors, executives, or related persons in the future, the Company seeks approval in principle to allow the Company to engage in such transactions if such transactions have commercial terms similar to those that a reasonable person would enter into with an unrelated party in the same circumstances, with bargaining power free from the influence of their status as a director, executive, or related person.
In addition, the Company will arrange for major shareholders, directors, and executives to submit information on their related persons to the Company Secretary's Office, including any changes, to ensure compliance with the regulations on the control of transactions with major shareholders, directors, executives, or persons related to such persons.
Future Trends in Related Party Transactions
The Company expects that in the future, the Company may continue to have transactions with persons and juristic persons who may have conflicts of interest with the Company. The related party transactions that occur must be transactions that are necessary and beneficial to the Company. The trend of future related party transactions will be related to ordinary course of business transactions, which are mainly transactions related to the provision of ordinary course of business services, such as lease of land and office space, as follows:
1. Provision of ordinary course of business services under the artist management agreement of persons who may have conflicts of interest with the Company. The trend of service provision transactions between the Company and related companies that will occur in the future will be transactions in the ordinary course of business of the Company from the artist management who are persons who may have conflicts of interest with the Company. However, if such transactions occur again in the future, the Company will comply with the policies set forth, with prices and service rates that are referenced to market prices, which are the same prices and conditions as those offered to outsiders, without causing any disadvantage to the Company.
2. Lease of land and buildings from persons who may have conflicts of interest with the Company. The trend of office building lease transactions. However, if such transactions occur again in the future, the Company will comply with the policies that have been clearly, fairly and not to cause the transfer of benefits. In this regard, if there are any related party transactions with persons or juristic persons who may have conflicts of interest, the Company will have the Audit Committee to examine the reasonableness of entering into the transactions and consider disclosing information on related party transactions or transactions that may have conflicts of interest to be accurate and complete. The Company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, regulations, notifications and orders of the Capital Market Supervisory Board, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the Stock Exchange of Thailand. However, when the Company has completed the construction of the new office building, the Company will not lease land and buildings from persons who may have conflicts of interest in the future.
